Stolen Treasures

A recent article at Recovering Grace, entitled “Moving On,” prompted me to think about the reason it is so difficult to move forward after being victimized by legalism.  As I have worked with those hurt by legalism over the years, I have often heard stories about what happened five, ten, maybe thirty years ago.  These folks still struggle against the lies they were told and the anger they continue to feel toward those who misused them.  I have come to the conclusion that a great deal of the difficulty of moving on has to do with the treasures that were stolen.

Each of the following could be an article in itself, but let me just introduce the problems legalism created by stealing these treasures.  You may think of more precious things that were stolen, but these are the ones that have come up most as I have communicated with victims.

The character of God.  Legalism presents an angry and vengeful God who wants to see us fail and then will punish us when we do.  He rejects us when we sin and puts us into situations to test our faithfulness.  He even punishes us for the things our great-grandparents did.  But this is not the God of the Bible.  Yes, I know the Bible speaks of the wrath against sin, but the message of love—forgotten by the legalist—is the primary message of Scripture.  God loves us and draws us by love.  When the love of God is set aside and His anger becomes the focus, where do we go when we are afraid?  The Lord may be a strong tower for His people, but the victims of legalism can’t run to Him and feel safe because they think He is angry with them.  I have often asked parents this: “When your children sin, and they will, do you want them to run to God or away from God?”  The character of the God you introduce is important.  Stealing away the love of God and substituting an angry or vindictive spirit is damaging.

The message of the Bible.  So many times people have told me that they simply cannot read the Bible anymore because all they see in it is condemnation.  The message of love and peace the Bible brings was stolen from them and replaced by a system that almost always forced them to see shame in its pages.  Not only was the Bible blamed for bringing the challenges of the legalist lifestyle, it was a constant killjoy.  “Because the Bible says,” was the refrain that supported every legalistic action, no matter how cruel.  But the Bible tells us of the love of God.  It was given to proclaim the message of His heart toward us—which is very good.  Stealing the real message of the Bible is a great sin against both the believer and the seeker.

The new heart of the believer.   How many times did we hear, “the heart is deceitful and desperately wicked”?  Victims of legalism are told never to trust their hearts, which meant never to trust their own judgment.  Sadly that meant that they were only to trust the judgment of those above them, which opened them to all kinds of abuse.  How can anyone go through life successfully and joyfully without the ability to trust their hearts?  I remember, when I first understood the great error of this, asking why we should delight in the Lord.  The Scripture says that if we delight in the Lord He will give us the desires of our hearts.  But if our hearts were as wicked as we were taught, why would God give us those desires?  Of course, we were told that He would change the desires of our hearts to the right thing, but that didn’t really help much.  The truth is that the believer has a new heart, one which the Lord uses to communicate with us.  When He connects to the new spirit in us, He connects to the new heart.  (See Ezekiel 11:19)  But when legalism stole away our ability to look within and trust our hearts, it took away our opportunity to hear the voice of our Lord.

The love and joy of others.  Legalism is a system of condemnation and comparison.  It sets us up to put others down.  If I can’t ever be good enough, I can at least be better than you.  We learned to judge and condemn others, rather than to understand them.  We learned to compare ourselves with them, rather than to listen and care.  We learned to keep them at a distance just in case, rather than to love them.  In legalism, we learned to mistrust God, others and ourselves.  But the Lord gave us each other for good.  We learn love from each other and others give us an outlet for our love.  Relationships are good.  Yes, they can be difficult, but they are meant to teach us about ourselves and how to trust God.  The message from the beginning, according to John (1 Jn 3:11) was that we should love one another.  But legalism pushes us away from each other.


I have come to believe that those who leave legalism must rediscover these treasures.  Some will seek them outside the faith.  Others will stumble around trying to find them within different legalist systems.  But they know, in every part of their being, that the treasures are worth seeking.

So let me summarize what I have found.

God loves you.  He has never not loved you and He has never stopped loving you.  Nothing you have done has changed His love for you.  All that He has done, through Jesus, has been because of His love for you.

The Bible consistently tells of this love, if you can look past the old legalist system to see the truth.  I have suggested that people read through the book of John just for one purpose, to see the love of God.  The message is very clear.  From beginning to end, the Bible tells of God’s love.

Those who have come to Jesus have received from Him a new heart.  It’s true!  The old has passed away and the new has come.  If you listen for God’s voice, you will hear words of love and affirmation.  Never will He condemn or shame you; that’s another voice.  Always He calls with a kind voice of acceptance.  And you can trust that He will lead you, through your heart, because of His love.

Others are good for you.  Yes, they struggle and stumble through life just like you do.  They sin and they hurt people.  But you don’t have to trust them in order to enjoy them or even love them.  You are called to trust the Lord.  He may lead you to people who are very different from you and you will learn from them.  We were meant to live in relationship with many people and God expresses His creativity in the styles of their lives.  Put away your expectations and let others fail.  Then you will begin to see how God loves you even through others.

Whatever time it takes, seek the treasures.  They are still yours.



Filed under heart, Legalism, Relationship

4 responses to “Stolen Treasures

  1. HopefulSorrow

    I mistakenly entered into a friendship with a legalistic narcissist (great combination, huh?). The damage that has been done has left me with my head spinning. I still have her voices in my head reminding me that her decisions are “what’s best.” What resonates most with me in this post is the comparison trap. Legalism sets us up to adopt false standards (based on maintaining one’s “image” of being the perfect Christian) and then to compare others by those standards. As I maintain no contact with this former “friend” who really just used me as her supply, I find myself enjoying the freedom the grace of God brings. Thank you for this post.

    • My blog began as an attempt to help people find their way out of legalism into grace. As I understood more about narcissism, I realized that there is a strong connection between narcissism and legalism. Many of the legalists I knew exhibited narcissistic characteristics and most of the teachers did. And you are right, comparison is an important part of both legalism and narcissism.

  2. Prairiemom

    You are so right. Legalism is so terribly destructive. One thing that it “stole” from me for a time was a teachable heart and the ability to be grateful for good biblical teaching. I had learned to equate having a critical spirit with spiritual discernment. I thought that the “right” way to listen to a sermon, read a Bible study book, or to take part in a Sunday School class was to do so actively LOOKING for any hint of false teaching in the message so that I would not “be deceived.” I learned that I should always expect false teaching in everything and that a truly wise Christian could find and point out false teaching anywhere. So while I should have been learning and growing from the wisdom of godly teachers, I was on my guard, studying each word so I could compare it to scripture and “catch” the lies before they caught me.

    If a person is always anticipating false teaching, it is easy to find even where it does not exist. This fear of course led to pride, which prevented me from learning ANYTHING. I have since discovered that a critical spirit and spiritual discernment are two totally different entities; one is a man-made sin and the other is both God-given and learned. Of course, there definitely ARE some false and destructive teachings within the church (including legalistic teachings), but it is a teachable spirit and the ability to learn from others and grow in God’s Word that will help me to weed out that sort of thing. By instilling suspicion of others’ teachings, legalists can keep the monopoly on people’s minds.

    • Very good point! The only good teacher was THE teacher. In my experience, we were to suspect everyone and everything except THE teacher. When he spoke, we were to set aside our doubts and questions because we were neither smart enough nor good enough to judge what he said. We were actually told that the Lord would eventually show us the truth of what THE teacher said and he gave us examples of people who disagreed at first and then were led to his perspective.

      I like this line: “By instilling suspicion of others’ teachings, legalists can keep the monopoly on people’s minds.”

      Part of the problem is that those who eventually realize that THE teacher is faulty often give up on all teachers and all truth. They abandon the faith in favor of their critical spirit. I understand this, but it is very sad. And, you are right, trusting the voice of the Lord through good teaching is a treasure that has been stolen.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s